- 1991 - 2006: James W. Deatherage
- 1983 - 1990: Harry Shumer
- 1978 - 1982: Lloyd Shonyo
- 1955 - 1977: Leslie Eggleston
- 1937 - 1957: Jay W. Haymaker
- 1927 - 1936: Rush W. Irsh
- 1923 - 1926: Willis Watson
- 1919 - 1922: Lenard Harvey
- 1913 - 1918: H.J. Craig
- 1911 - 1912: J.W. Agustine
- 1905 - 1910: William L. Morris
- 1901 - 1914: William Bridges
- 1890 - 1900: Henry Lloyd
- 1881 - 1889: H. Clay Webster
- 1880: Woodard Hodgsons
- 1879: Edward Kyle
- 1879: William H. Burch
- 1878 - 1877: S.A. Safford
- 1876 - 1875: Jonas C. Baer
- 1874: W.W. Remino
- 1873: Jonas C. Baer
- 1872: William H. Hall
- 1871: Thomas Gorden
- 1870: George W. Griffen
- 1869: Ira H. Lucus
- 1868: William A. Stump
- 1867: M. Mills Crary
- 1866: Joseph H. Macon
- 1865: James Henderson
- 1864: Lewis Conley
- 1863 - 1862: Samuel E. Blair
